Germany: Cologne (Köln) cathedral and city
Score: 65

"The place has developed into a modern city. If a tourist goes to Cologne expecting a city that matches the medieval cathedral, she or he will be deceived."

"The protection of the cathedral itself has improved, but the landscape surrounding the property is a permanent problem; it is situated almost at the modern commercial center and central train station—the surrounding space is not in the right proportion and there is no consistent style to the commercial center buildings."

"The monument itself is impressive, but the area around it largely spoils the scenery. Tourism is more linked to the intangible heritage of Cologne, a town known for its party-loving people, and especially its carnival."

"Köln city has built its tourist attraction around the cathedral. Through its information center, brochures, and guided tours, visitors have a wonderful experience of its cathedral. Of all the European cities I have visited, Cologne is the most 'tourist friendly' and the attraction seems to be the most sustainable."

Germany: Upper Middle Rhine Valley
Score: 74

"One of the important aspects of the heritage of the Rhine Valley is as a traditional transport corridor—with river barge traffic and two important railway lines.This should not be lost in the interest of historic heritage preservation, as the Rhine is Europe's greatest living river."

"Looks good and faithful to its historical character."

"Well-managed; tourism development is currently compatible with the ecological and historic character of Rhine environs."

"Great site with diverse potential, but lacks tourist infrastructure."

"It's a bore mostly."

"Good blend of tourism and heritage maintenance with the traditional agricultural economy."