Ecuador: Galápagos Islands
Score: 44

"All the superlatives, both good and bad. Unsurpassable aesthetic appeal and ecological quality. Social and cultural integrity are questionable due to the large number of immigrants from the mainland who have little understanding and appreciation for the natural values of the Galápagos."

"The islands retain a staggering 95 percent of their endemic, or native, species, a feat unparalleled on any other archipelago in the world."

"Striking for the unique wildlife but evidence of the threats, such as feral animals, introduced domestics, and exotic plants are obvious everywhere. The towns on the islands are rapidly growing and packed with tourists. The park service appears weak and struggling."

"From the tourist's view, the trails and islands seem well maintained. Boat landings and groups are regulated. No trash or degradation of natural sites evident, and animals still quite docile. The political organization of the site is, however, a mess, with continuing change of directors and bureaucratic problems. Population growth, fishermen, both sea-cucumber and offshore Japanese, are a major threat. The Charles Darwin Foundation is its saving grace."

"Tourism growth must be carefully examined. Would recommend capping size of boats allowed in archipelago. Must not give up on dialogue with fishermen and other local citizens."

"The outlook is pretty bleak.The islands seem to be at a crossroads. Discussions of increasing the size of cruise ships and the corruption surrounding illegal fishing activities and immigration pose serious threats."