St. Martin/St. Maarten
Score: 47

"The Dutch side is a mess: out of control high-rise and strip development, loss of community character, traffic congestion, and schlock. The French side looks great by comparison."

"Development and cosmopolitan population out of control. Crime rate is high, but the island remains a popular destination for casino gambling and nightlife."

"Food is fabulous everywhere, and with all the hustle, there are still peaceful beaches and low-key places to visit."

"The French side is much more aesthetically appealing, both natural and human-made, than the Dutch side. The latter is overdeveloped, and Philipsburg is dominated by shops catering to cruise ship travelers."