Scotland: Edinburgh historic areas

Score: 76

NOTE: These evaluations were made before the Scottish government approved the controversial Caltongate development for the historic center of Edinburgh. For more on this issue, see Destination Watch in our October 2008 issue.

"A spectacular natural setting and has a built environment from the old town to the new town that creates a unique blend."

"Changed over the last 40 years from a dull, reticent city to a vibrant one."

"Exquisite blend of past and present, without the kowtowing to tourists."