Georgia (U.S.): Atlanta historic areas

Score: 46

"The contrast between the Martin Luther King, Jr., Historic Site and the few surrounding buildings is jarring, but perhaps is an interpretive opportunity. In other areas of the city historic buildings seem to be marooned."

"Atlanta historic sites are isolated. They fail a cohesion test. Sweet Auburn area is sound, but much of the historic urban fabric is lost."

"Historic Atlanta? Gimme a break! A soul-less downtown and exceptional urban sprawl, with some dusty little relics in neglected corners, are all that can be called 'historic.'"

"The influx of non-Southerners in Atlanta has regrettably resulted in a lack of appreciation for the city's commercial core, historic neighborhoods, and cultural identity. Looks like 'Anywhere U.S.A.' Old Atlanta is still there, however; you just have to look hard for it."

Georgia (U.S.): Savannah

Score: 71

"A nice historic city with a waterfront area that has turned into a minor Bourbon Street. All in all, the architectural heritage is in good shape, and tourism is not smothering the history."

"Historic fabric is very well cared for, and new development is mostly kept in character with the old, with some notable lapses. The total tourist package, which includes a good amount of cultural/folk emphasis, is balanced."

"A great city for walking. The squares in the early town plan provide good reference points."

"The aesthetic appeal continues to be first-rate. However, crime and violence continue to affect the social/cultural integrity of the destination."

"The African-American history is lost behind cheap tours of ghosts and haunted mansions."